Copy article

Plans for 99% mortgages apparently scrapped - reaction from brokers

ended 01. March 2024

The Chancellor has apparently scrapped plans for a 99% mortgage after resistance from the banking community, according to Government insiders, it has been reported. Newspage asked brokers for their views, which can be found below.

15 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Star Quote
Copy

Editor
Andrew Montlake
Managing Director at Coreco
There were always more questions than answers around this policy and the reality was that lenders would not have been able to make this work in the way the Government thought. Income multiple limits, affordability, capital adequacy rules, not to mention the real risk of negative equity could all easily have turned the policy into a damp squib that helped very few. If they had bothered to consult with the industry before promoting the idea, they would have understood this earlier. As a result, they have now left more prospective young buyers disappointed and a housing market bereft of any innovative policies that actually help increase the supply of property or first-time buyers to own one. Tax cuts alone will not turn around their fortunes and the Chancellor needs to be careful of a repeat of the shambles that we saw under Truss.
Star Quote
Copy

Editor
Emma Jones
Managing Director at Whenthebanksaysno.co.uk
This scheme would never have ended well, with the risk of negative equity the major downside. We need something better from the Government that offers solid and well thought through support for those looking to get onto the property ladder, not a scheme that has the potential to hit homeowners hard a few years down the line.
Star Quote
Copy

Platinum
Simon Bridgland
Director at Charwin Private Clients
We should be thankful for small mercies. If the idea is scrapped, it will be looked back at as a “what the hell were we thinking?” moment. Of course we need something to help boost the property market, but unless Jeremy Hunt can pull a rabbit out of the hat, we will be left with nothing to make a real difference. Is another stamp duty holiday on the cards? Let’s hope not. That will simply lead to artificially inflated prices.
Star Quote
Copy

Ying Tan
CEO at Habito
The 99% mortgage was only ever a headline maker, and not fit for purpose. I am glad it has been stopped before it started. Homebuyers need and deserve a better thought-out scheme that is sustainable, affordable and lasts the distance. Back to the drawing board Chancellor, but do keep engaging with the mortgage industry.
Star Quote
Copy

Rowan Frayling
Managing Director at J Finance
Near 100% mortgages turn out to be a bad idea. Next up in today’s news, the pope is catholic and bears do indeed defecate in the woods. Thankfully this ridiculous attempt to grab votes from the younger generation doesn’t sound like it will become a reality.
Star Quote
Copy

Peter Stamford
Mortgage Expert at Stamford Home Finance
Whilst this will be dissapointing news for a large number of potential first-time buyers, it is clearly the best outcome for the stability of the housing market in general. This idea would have likely seen an artifically inflated housing bubble, which, when it burst, could have trapped a lot of first-time buyers in negative equity.
Star Quote
Copy

Graham Cox
Director at Bridging Hub
I'm not surprised the banks were against the introduction of 1% deposit mortgages. It's a terrible idea. With major lenders warning house prices could fall this year, the risk of falling into negative equity and being repossessed would be enormous. That the Government were even floating the proposition shows how desperate they are.
Copy

Editor
Riz Malik
Independent Financial Adviser at R3 Wealth
As much as the UK property market needs stimulation, this was never the answer. Unfortunately, we have a Chancellor looking for a stay of execution who has run out of time and ideas. I was expecting big things from this Budget but I think we will all be disappointed like a child who gets clothes on their birthday.
Copy

Editor
Harps Garcha
Director at Brooklyns Financial
The decision to scrap the 99% mortgage scheme may leave many first-time buyers feeling disheartened, but the reasons behind the move are hardly surprising. Affordability challenges for banks, particularly in pricey regions like the South East, coupled with the risk of negative equity for new buyers, made the short-term appeal of such a stimulus difficult to justify. While the housing market undoubtedly needs a boost, this scheme could have backfired spectacularly. Instead, policymakers should focus on wider and longer term solutions that tackle underlying issues like housing affordability and supply shortages.
Copy

Editor
Katy Eatenton
Mortgage & Protection Specialist at Lifetime Wealth Management
I am glad this idea was short-lived. It was a false ray of light for borrowers, and the current market is too volatile to guarantee that they wouldn’t slip into negative equity immediately. Disaster has been averted if true.
Copy

Editor
Michelle Lawson
Director at Lawson Financial
Near disaster has been averted if this is truly the case. This was a hare-brained idea from day one and could have put many borrowers at real risk of negative equity. The banks seem to have learned from the Global Financial Crisis, even if the Government had not.
Copy

Platinum
Jack Tutton
Director at SJ Mortgages
This is disappointing news for first-buyers as this seemed to attract a lot of attention. The government would have had to offer significant guarantees for lenders to enter the market at that loan to value, and the crash of 2008 will still be very much in their thoughts. Maybe lenders could look to particularly help single first-time buyers, who often struggle to keep up with ever escalating house prices.
Copy

Richard Jennings CeMAP
Founder & Managing Director at Richard Jennings Mortgage Services
Thankfully the lenders and banks have persuaded the Government to bench this idea. 99% mortgages were never the answer, more a vote winner from a younger demographic. This is what happens when Government policies are designed to win votes rather than genuinely support the people of this country. A potential 2008 has thankfully been diverted.. It's now time to stop coming up with voted-grabbing schemes and actually deliver on the one thing we really need, namely to build some more houses, and at pace.
Copy

Matthew Jackson
Director at Mint FS
I think most brokers would agree that the UK housing market requires invigorating, and generally I would welcome any news schemes that might achieve that. However, the proposed 99% mortgage scheme was impracticable and unworkable. I suspected at the time that is was merely "click bait" designed to paint a positive picture of the Government. Brokers across the country will breathe a sigh of relief this morning as they will not have to deal with prospective buyers who expect to buy a home with little to no income and who would be at risk of negative equity.
Copy

Gary Bush
Financial Adviser at MortgageShop.com
As we wondered at the time of the announcement this dream scheme by the government was just a soundbite to play to the general public with the general election looming, there wasn't any real substance to be found in the release and the promised fine details weren't subsequently provided. It's no surprise that the lenders might not be doing cartwheels over this meddling they already have great products available to help first-time buyers, they might need a decent mortgage advice firm to navigate you safely through them but the lender product availability isn't the problem. We are growing tired of responding that the Housing Minister needs to look again at the Shared Ownership scheme and bring the lease terms offered by the Housing Associations up to date/remove the draconian lending restrictions - to revitalise the property building agenda.