Copy article

4-day week: "A clearer focus on outputs over inputs may be just the thing to jolt the British economy into action"

ended 30. August 2024

According to reports late yesterday and overnight, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner is planning to give UK workers new rights to demand a four-day week. 

Under the new law, companies will be required to offer flexible working from day one unless it is “not reasonably feasible”. Importantly, employees would still be required to work their full contracted hours to receive their pay in full but could compress those hours into a shorter week.

Newspage asked HRs and other experts for their initial thoughts on this. Is it a positive step for employee wellbeing and work/life balance or could it be a blow to productivity and the UK economy? Also, how hard will this law be to enforce and what other legal ramifications and complexities could arise? Also, how will businesses react to this? Their views will appear below until midday.

7 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Star Quote
Copy

I witness countless capable women stuck in roles far below their potential, simply because these positions offer the flexibility they need. After losing my husband to cancer during maternity leave, I left a job I loved because a four-day work week wasn’t an option. Whilst it might be a logistical nightmare to deliver for some businesses, we’re currently driving away talented workers who could contribute so much more if flexible working options were prioritised.
Star Quote
Copy

If implemented well, the potential benefits of the 4-day week for employees are wide-ranging, with positive impacts for individuals, their teams and business performance. We worked with Highgate IT Solutions in 2023 to evaluate their '4DW' trial and discovered that giving employees the option of time back with no loss of pay benefited their work/life balance, mental health and overall wellbeing. The results showed the new work pattern improved workplace resilience through the development of new skills, enhanced flexibility and adaptability, and functioning with greater focus, productivity, engagement and performance. They never went back. However, introducing flexibility also has potential to undermine team relationships and derail business objectives if not handled carefully. Highgate found that keeping staff at the centre of planning, by providing training and a buddy system, was crucial to ensure they were well supported and to make changing work patterns sustainable.
Star Quote
Copy

A clearer focus on outputs over inputs may be just the thing to jolt the British economy into action. This comes instinctively to the very best leaders, the very best companies. They invest in their people; they give space for initiative and creativity. Unsurprisingly, they recruit and retain the best. This plan throws down the gauntlet. It may be just the catalyst employees and business need. This plan, at least on face value, may be difficult to reconcile with the government’s stated drive for growth. Yet the apparent contradiction may not withstand considered reflection. We're in a race for scarce talent and the expectations of the workers of today and tomorrow bear little comparison to those of former generations.
Copy

Gone are the days of a four-day work week being merely a whisper in the corridors of progressive workplaces; it is now a potential legislative reality. Yet, despite the natural ‘too good to be true’ suspicion surrounding anything that feels remotely utopian, this policy could be a beacon of hope for improved mental health and enhanced productivity. Furthermore, it is hard to discount the overwhelmingly positive results from the recent policy trial in 2022. Of course, implementing a four-day week is not without its legal complexities, as while employees may be dancing in the streets, employers could find themselves caught in a tango of logistical nightmares, increased operational costs and reduced output. Yet by daring to dream of a radical new approach to work, it has the potential to turn the vision of a balanced life and a thriving economy into a tangible reality.
Copy

With further changes to day one rights, Labour are certaintly keeping employers on their toes. Whilst changes like this can be easier to incoroporate and accomodate in larger organisations, they can put significant strain on SMEs. The 4-day working week is already common in some organisations and we know flexibility in how and where employees work is often seen as a valuable benefit. It's great to see that this may become something that more can benefit from. Putting employees in the driving seat of their own work schedule can drive productivity but it is important to remember there is not a one size fits all and the application and implementation of these initiatives is the key to success.
Copy

Empowering workers with the right to request a four-day week is a bold step towards modernising our work culture. While it promises enhanced work-life balance and potential productivity gains, it must remain an option, not a mandate, to accommodate diverse business needs and economic realities.
Copy

Whilst this law change sounds like a continuation of the drive towards an entirely employee-led world, there are commercial positives. The 4 day working week is very common in the NHS and already works very successfully. Constant developments in tech means a 4 day working week does not automatically mean businesses have to stop on the 5th day - not everyone wants a Friday off. And with thought, some office roles can still be hugely successful on a 4 day productive week - opposed to stringing it out over 5. Allowing a 4 day productive week (importantly, under the requirement that business goals are still met) could mean that you have a more productive and motivated workforce as they are able to meet their outside needs/goals whether its caring for family members, volunteering, or other outside interests, without the stress of trying to 'do it all'. A motivated workforce is a psychologically safe workforce and they're less likely to turn their heads for an extra £5k elsewhere.