Copy article

Ticking Mortgage Timebomb

ended 18. December 2023

A journalist at The Independent is writing a piece on the ticking mortgage timebomb that is due to go off in 2024 as circa 1.4m people come off their ultra-low fixed rates and transition into a whole new world of pain. How big a problem could this be, could debt problems and mortgage arrears spiral in 2024, and will the stress testing lenders have done prove effective or fail to contain the financial impact that's about to hit (given other pressures, e.g. inflation, weakening economy)? In short, how big could this mortgage timebomb be?

17 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

2024 will be a defining year for many people, with over 1 million borrowers needing to budget for a considerable increase in their payments. In particular, there will be many mortgage holders with 5-year deals arranged pre-COVID, so they will potentially be the worst affected, not only from rate shock but maybe significant lifestyle changes too where the low mortgage rates have masked other financial issues. With hopes of improving inflation data, continued downward mortgage rate adjustments and other household costs starting to fall, the impact may not be quite as bad as before, but it will still deliver a serious financial shock to many over the coming months.
Copy

Mortgage stress-tests over the recent past were unlikely to have taken into account this perfect storm of high utility bills and the cost of living crisis. Coupled with higher inflation, it's pretty obvious that ordinary people are going to struggle with these higher payments come next year. We need lenders to help reverse the potential credit issues by becoming more flexible with rates and possibly interest-only criteria - this being a last-resort solution for some.
Copy

This mortgage time-bomb will be nuclear for many households with the fallout being widespread and long-lasting. Whilst we expect base rate and lender rates to fall over 2024 it won’t be enough to protect most. A jump of 3% or more will challenge even the most prepared households.
Copy

This is not new news now so I don't know where anybody that is not prepared for this has been for the last 12-18mths. Most people are well equipped for the increased payments thanks to the stress testing although they may not like to pay more and, as always, there will be a small percentage that won't be able to absorb this. It is very important that people talk things through with their mortgage adviser to assess their options and, don't forget, if rates continue to come down further, it is only the broker who will tell you, the consumer, this as the lenders won't and don't if you go directly to them.
Copy

We are amid a cost-of-living crisis, and this is far from over, with millions already affected and struggling in a big way. But 2023 was just the start, with an estimated 1.4M people facing ultra-low fixed-rate maturities, and facing significant increases in the cost of their mortgages. OK, so some may well have dodged a bullet by coming out of their rates in 2024 rather than the peak interest rates of 2023, but many will be ill-prepared for what's coming. There is a trend already, with people increasing their utilization of unsecured credit to get by, and these people, along with lower-income households will likely be hardest hit. Even with the saving grace of the rate war being fought by mortgage lenders, some are going to tip over the edge, finding themselves with more month than money. 2024 will be a continuation of what 2023 has seen, and the consequences for some will be dire.
Copy

Stress testing is done for this very reason, so this on its own should not have too detrimental an impact on borrowers, however, since then, a lot has happened. COVID has left a lasting legacy which permanently changed how a lot of people choose to work, inadvertently eliminating themselves from a lender's preferred criteria. Additionally, food, fuel and other bills have surged with many of the 1.4M households sprouting families obviously all placing extra burden on household budgets.
Since these borrowers took out the mortgages, some would have gone on to use other forms of credit, car loans or other finance arrangements many on variable rates of interest all placing further pressure on households.
Levels of income and job changes aside, those who have not over committed themselves should be okay, but those who chose to live life on credit, and thats a sizeable amount of the 1.4M, need to change things fast. For some it's not so much a time bomb, more an atom bomb.
Copy

There are 1.4m people out there at this moment who are hoping that interest rates will plummet next year to save them eye-watering increases in their monthly mortgage payments. We're already seeing clients who have had to take out increased short-term credit, whether it's credit cards or loans just to cover the basics. Mortgage arrears have been increasing and we've had queries from clients already desperately looking for a way to stave off lenders from taking ownership of their homes. The stress testing from 5 years ago didn't cater for this perfect storm that's clear and I think there is a risk the government and lenders have become complacent in their thinking that we've turned the corner - far from it - we're in the eye of the storm and unless the headwinds change we're going to get hit with a record number of people falling on a credit nightmare.

Copy

The Bank of England are taking credit for getting inflation down, but the rate would have come down without central bank action. The small amount of households that have been effected by rate increases is negligible compared to those coming off their fixed rates next year, and inflation is already on route to target. Andrew Bailey has gone too far, and if he keeps rates higher for longer, as he has indicated, he will inflict a world of pain on families that do not need to shoulder the burden. The Bank of England should start slashing rates soon, not just to alleviate the pain for over a million people, but also to stave off a recession that is, almost certainly, down the road. If the Bank doesn't act we could see a recession like 2008 and repossessions, that are already high, will go through the roof.
Copy

The recent Bank of England data revealed mortgage arrears hit a 6-year high which shows the impact rate increases have had on many mortgage holders already. With 1.4m people set to come off low rates in 2024, it is likely the problem will worsen. On the ground, I have seen an increase in clients with missed payments on unsecured lending and I have seen many clients looking at ways to save money at this difficult time. The positives right now are that predicted rates for 2024 look like they will be on average lower than what we have seen in 2023, so it might be the impact for some may be more manageable. However, we have all seen how quickly things can change and I think many will struggle with the added pressures of a weak economy and inflation still high.
Copy

Borrowers on historically low fixed rates will have been watching the last 18 months with a mixture of shock and horror as the Bank of England rates rose. Those whose household incomes are already stretched with the cost of living crisis will be praying for something of a miracle in 2024, but it's unlikely rates will dip down soon, certainly not to levels they were 5 years ago. For many homeowners a big hike in mortgage costs is going to be another debt burden too far and it's not only in lower-income families that we'll see the impact. Lenders, brokers and borrowers need to brace themselves for the challenges ahead. The impact of money issues on mental health is going to be a double-whammy for a lot of families.
Copy

It starts with a Mortgage Timebomb, but this next year will be when the Car Leasing and Finance deals of recent years come back to bite - yes the School Run may be more comfortable in a brand-new SUV than a second-hand Focus Estate, but just wait until those monthly payments obliterate many re-mortgage options, just when they most need them. Borrowers need to take heed of Brokers who suggest starting a review process six months ahead of the mortgage deal ending!
Copy

The timebomb could be huge and potentially last for another year or two. When borrowers were obtaining fixed rates at 1% a few years ago, they were being stress tested at rates lower than today, but without the much higher costs of living we are now seeing. Add higher interest rates to higher living costs and the pain borrowers will suffer could be immense. This is why the government have been pushing the mortgage charter onto lenders, but this can only go so far.
Back in the early 90's, most borrowers had variable rate mortgages, which meant the pain was instant, but so was the slow cure. Today, the pain higher rates are meant to cause filters into the market much more slowly with most borrowers on fixed rates. This means the road to recovery is likely to take much longer.
Copy

Mortgage affordability has been stress tested by lenders for quite some time now, ie lenders have to assess mortgage affordability on the basis that interest rates will rise. So although 1.4m people will be faced with higher mortgage payments in 2024, in theory, this should be affordable to them. Although people certainly aren't going to be happy about this, especially in a general election year!
Copy

Anyone remortgaging next year will face eyewatering increases in their monthly payments. The economy is already on the brink of recession, now 1.4 million borrowers will have hundreds of pounds less a month to spend on the high street. It's a vicious cycle that will only make matters worse. But this is what you get when the economy is based on overinflated house prices.
Copy

The amount of very low existing fixed rates coming off a deal in 2024 is a frightening problem for a lot of mortgage account holders. There is a two-fold problem, firstly the rate shock/new monthly payment will be hard to facilitate in tight household monthly budgets. Secondly, if your existing lenders fixed rate replacement is ill-timed and not tracked by a qualified adviser for you - you could end up on the wrong deal, and indeed that deal could be higher than other more competitive lenders but the lender's now tightened affordability assessments don't allow you to apply to a new lender.
Copy

I'm not sure it's a ticking mortgage time bomb, but it may be a ticking car finance/credit card/personal loan/subscription service time bomb. UK households are generally very good at prioritising mortgage repayments over other spending, so I would expect many will forgo these other expenses before they would risk missing their mortgage payment. Many clients I have helped review their mortgage over the past year have been prepared for a jump in repayments, you'd have to have been living at the North Pole to not know mortgage interest rates aren't at 1% or 2% anymore, I've then been able to help them manage the increase by looking at options like increasing their repayment terms. In some cases, although a jump up, clients have been surprised at the level of the increase because they thought it was going to be much worse than it ended up being; it's certainly worth speaking to a mortgage broker to understand what level of increase you are looking at and what your options are.
Copy


While pinpointing the precise outcome remains challenging, it's reasonable to assert that ultra-low interest rates may have stretched affordability to its limits for many individuals. Consequently, the prospect of re-mortgaging at current rates undoubtedly raises concerns about a potential increase in defaults and repossessions among this demographic. The critical question now is the extent of this segment and its impact.