Copy article

Brokers - what is your wishlist for the new housing minister?

Journalist: John Fitzsimons, Freelance

ended 14. November 2023

Morning brokers

We have had yet another change of housing minister in the latest reshuffle, with Rachel McLean given the boot after only nine months.

https://www.mortgagesolutions.co.uk/news/2023/11/13/another-month-another-minister-sunak-removes-maclean-from-housing-post-as-part-of-reshuffle/

We'd love to get your thoughts on the merry-go-round that is the housing minister brief, and whether that is making the situation with housing worse.

We'd also love to hear what your wishlist for her replacement, Lee Rowley, is. What should be the priority for any new housing minister? 

Any and all thoughts very welcome on this!

15 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

By the time Lee Rowley has changed his LinkedIn profile he will probably be gone. This highlights the fundamental issue with any key long term policy making decision in modern day politics. This is also the reason why the housing crisis in the UK will never be solved.
Copy

What we want from the new housing minister is some longevity and consistency. Being the 16th housing minister since 2010 this has been severely lacking previously. But with a general election next year I have very low expectations on the impact he can bring to the role.
Copy

The new Housing Minister needs to find a way of staying in position for more than a few months, assuming he does that Mr Rowley needs to continue to work on Leasehold reform, find ways to encourage private landlords to stay in the market, and influence builders to develop sites with a higher percentage of smaller properties, ideally priced for younger, first-time buyers. Nothing that takes 5 minutes, unfortunately, as his predecessors have found.
Copy

Same wishlist for every Housing Minister we have had: Increase the supply of affordable housing, improve the quality of housing, protect tenant rights, address homelessness - no one has stayed in the job long enough, to follow any of these through. I think there is more chance of getting a tan off a light bulb, than a housing minister who can deliver on the issues above.
Copy

Quite frankly, just by having a good tenure will improve things. Given half a chance of making his seat warm should prove beneficial to the housing department. How can any minister stand a chance of making improvements if they don't get given the time to do it? Hopefully, he will be here to see the cement dry on current housing developments and realise, "Oh we need more!"
Copy

This is an embarrassing state of affairs in the continuous circus also known as our Government. The new housing minister is not only the 16th since the Tories came to power in 2010, but he is in the job for the 2nd time. My wishes, in no particular order, are that he is in the seat long enough to warm it up, he listens to and takes advice from those who know the sector and implements them before this sector implodes. More importantly, there should be focus on this role being a senior ministerial role. Housing is a fundamental basic need as is health and education and should be treated as such rather than a political hot potato and not just a feeder role for junior ministers.
Copy

Some commitment to the role would be a start, not using the role as a stepping stone for other jobs within the government. We need a pledge to build more social housing and also build more affordable homes we don't need any silly schemes which inflate house prices we simply need genuinely affordable homes not 3 bed homes for £500,000.
Copy

With change comes disruption and delays. Hopefully leasehold reform is prioritised, but it is hard to see any real progress being made before the next election. The housing sector is crying out for stability and reform to tackle some of the big issues that have been lingering for far too long.
Copy

The number of housing ministers that have come and gone over the last decade without any consequences is now beyond a joke. There is hardly a reason for landlords and renters to be optimistic that the next one will be of any consequence as the revolving door of housing ministers turns once more. For a sector like ours that thrives on certainty and wants to see a long-term plan for the housing market, such discontinuity in leadership is a significant concern and actively undermines investment and long-term commitment across the board. Maclean had only been in post for barely nine months, and we are back to Lee Rowley who was Truss' infamous 49-day Housing Minister. The government has to get a grip on the housing crisis – it is screaming for urgent action to help landlords and tenants alike. We need continuity, the development of a strategic plan and the certainty that ensures housing is planned, designed and built to meet the needs of current and future communities across the country.
Copy

The UK is never going to gain the much-needed traction in housebuilding with a change at the top coming so frequently, so my wish would be for some longevity in post - and then you consider the looming election and wonder..........................
Copy

I believe that the newly appointed housing minister should prioritise the availability of more affordable housing options, especially in light of the current higher interest rates. The rising cost of rent in the rental market has posed significant challenges for many first-time buyers, making it increasingly difficult for them to step onto the property ladder.

I feel the government consider implementing a mortgage guarantee scheme for lenders, enabling them to offer 100% mortgages. Such an initiative would not only provide a crucial lifeline for first-time buyers but also stimulate activity in the housing market. By reducing the barriers to entry, this measure has the potential to encourage more individuals to consider homeownership, ultimately fostering a healthier and more inclusive property market.

Copy

Lee Rowley, like his predecessors, is unlikely to be in post for very long. But long-term, we need a complete change of mindset around housing. We line the pockets of private landlords every year to the tune of billions of pounds in housing benefit, discretionary income has been slashed, homelessness and food banks are on the increase and the economy is stagnating. All off the back of the 'rising house prices are good' mantra. That may be true for the Tories benefactors, the banks and house builders, but the consequences for the rest of us are devastating.

The remedy is not rocket science. Build social housing at massive scale, stop Right to Buy, and include house prices in the 2% inflation target. Those three things alone would make a huge difference.
Copy

Try and hold onto the position until after the Christmas presents have been opened. This role is the poisoned chalice, we have had more ministers for housing since 2010 than we have had Chelsea managers. The task is very simple, build more affordable houses, and make the planning process more simple.
Copy

Stability would be a key one, just look at Watford Football club you cant keep changing who is in charge every 5 mins and expect to be in the premier league (sorry watford fans). With house builders slowing, affordable housing slowing, interest rates have risen the market is currently in a mess and needs someone to come in and take it by the scruff of the neck and sort it out, but they are going to need time, is alex fergerson free?
Copy

Stop screwing things up with big changes. If you need to make changes, schedule them over a certain amount of time and be transparent. The general public need stability. Make gov rental contracts be more acceptable to lenders. So instead of 2 year AST, maybe go with 6 monthly, so lenders can be happier with the agreement.