Copy article

Average mortgage fees rise

Journalist: Callum Mason, i

ended 01. December 2023

Mortgage product fees have risen on average. At £1,108, the average fee currently charged on a fixed rate mortgage deal (not including no-fee products) has risen by £21 since the start of November 2023 according to Moneyfacts.

Does this show that those looking to get a new mortgage need to be careful about just looking at the fee? What should they be considering holistically when getting a new mortgage?

19 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Borrowers should always consider the overall cost of a product including any arrangement fees, and all brokers will compare mortgages on this basis. Lately, due to higher rates putting pressure on affordability both on residential and buy-to-let mortgages due to the required stress-testing, many lenders have been tweaking their product line-up to give options with lower rates but larger and in some cases percentage fees. That way the lender can still generate the same income from the product, but the headline rate attracts more clients and is gentler on the affordability calculations. Borrowers who only focus on and compare the headline rate will often end up paying more overall.
Copy

Borrowers should always consider the overall cost of the product not just the headline rate and any borrower using a broker will almost certainly looking at total cost over the 2, 3 or 5 year period lenders right now will be chasing lending targets by dropping rates but at the same time having product fees for borrowers who wish to take advantage of the lower rate so always get advice to ensure you are best placed going forward.
Copy

Arrangement fees should always be factored in when sourcing a client's mortgage; for instance, the very cheapest buy-to-let rates will include a percentage fee which can be eye-watering. Obviously you secure a cheaper rate by paying a fee, but this may not returned over the deal period and that can be worked out very easily. My rule of thumb is the lower the loan, the less likely it is that paying a fee for a cheap rate will work in the client's favour.
Copy

Although, fairly insignificant it is a rise none the less. Those looking for a new mortgage deal should always take into account the cost and impact of any fees the lender charges, especially if you are considering adding them to the loan. Adding a typical fee will add in the region of £5 per month to a typical 25 year mortgage. So an increase will of course cost you a little more, but it does usually come accompanied with a better rate than not paying a fee. The mortgage world is a changing market place, which put simply means go and get the deals whilst they are there, when the money has gone a new deal takes its place, (usually) but the lender may not have been able to get as good a deal at the wholesalers, so any extra cost they have is passed onto you the consumer. Lenders are always looking to make their shiny new product attractive to sell more of it, quicker. So if buyers are so rate fixated then they will simply do the cup trick with fees.
Copy

It's hardly surprising that mortgage fees are on the rise as lenders try to work out the magic formula to get their money out there again. Product design is one way they can do this, by offering more appealing headline interest rates, and at the same time, offsetting some of the interest into the fee charges. The low rate-higher fee or higher rate-lower fee equation is entirely subjective and depends on the applicant's circumstances and priorities. There is no overall right or wrong answer, one size does not fit all, and when money is tight, the overall cost to repay is not the primary consideration, it is the monthly payment. More than ever, get in touch with a mortgage professional, be open with them about what you want and let them cut through the increasing confusion on what is "best".
Copy

All advisers should compare products with or without fees to identify the right fee for the client. The issue is when adding these increasing fees to the mortgage the overall cost of the mortgage is also going to be more expensive over the life of the mortgage. So although the interest rate may look attractive with the higher fee it's important to compare the overall cost of the mortgage both with and without the fees added to the mortgage.
Copy

The need for advice has never been greater- best is not always cheapest!
Copy

As always the mortgage product is a combination of rate and fee, not either in isolation. Fees have edged higher with some lenders just so they can offer a better rate, in particular the Buy to Let market fees are substantially higher to offset lower rates. In all situations, our normal position is to work out the cost of any mortgage over the term of the deal, so if it is a 2yr product, you add 24 monthly payments, any fees payable, and deduct any incentives that may be on offer. That calculation is checked with every other similar deal to work out the 'cheapest' product. But if you are adding fees to the loan, remember they will need to be repaid some day. Speak to your Mortgage Broker who will do this analysis for you, and will recommend which is the best option for the many available.
Copy

When selecting a mortgage rate it is easy to be drawn in by the headline rate, but the fee lenders charge for a better rate can actually make a no fee product with a higher rate more cost effective. Fees vary but the average fee we see is £999. It's very easy to add this fee to the mortgage, so for some clients it doesn't feel like you are paying a fee at all, but you are actually paying interest over the longer term as a result. It's rarely cost effective to pay a fee when you have a low mortgage balance or looking at a 2 year fixed rate. However for some a lower monthly payment is more important right now in a cost of living crisis.
Copy

We have been talking about these eye-gouging fees since the end of last year. Average product fees in general, and the arrangement fees on buy-to-let mortgages in particular have become astronomical, with some charging up to 7 per cent of the loan size to have access to a better rate. This trend started following the Liz Truss era last year, with fees being cranked up to disproportionate levels to make deals look more attractive, when on the face of it, they may end up costing more at times because borrowers will continue to pay interest on accumulated arrangement fees. All of these large fees have become a necessity in order to satisfy the higher stress test requirements, the blame for which must lie at the feet of the FCA. More than ever, it is now imperative for the FCA to investigate how these fees can be brought in line and stop lenders profiteering on the back of these fees.
Copy

Lenders have been reducing rates since August to attract new business in a very slow market. I suspect they are trying to maintain margins somewhat by increasing product fees, as these are often overlooked by borrowers when considering overall cost. And if they're added to the loan, the lender receives extra interest which can add up over the mortgage term. A good broker will always find the best pound-for-pound deal for the client, factoring in all fees during the concessionary period, including product fees, valuation fees, cashback and so on.
Copy

The best mortgage deal for any given client is always a balance of interest rate, set-up fee and cashback. With interest rates being higher than many people have seen in quite a long time, fees have risen to help headline rates stay lower, some lenders may also have reduced or removed cashback from certain deals, again to maintain a better headline rate. Whenever you concentrate on just one element of a deal you are likely to end up in the wrong place, you always need to look at mortgages in the round and encompass all the elements that make up the overall cost to the borrower.
Copy

This is the lenders scrapping for business, where margins are tight, lenders will look to recover those costs with higher arrangement fees while offering a headline rate to attract more business. However, arrangement fees are always considered when we look at your mortgage to determine whether the higher fee is cost-effective for the lower rate, so generally finding the higher arrangement fees being more cost effective for those with higher mortgage balances.
The good news is that is show the lenders are continuing to be competitive and this is only great news for borrowers.
Copy

Product fees are something that all advisers would consider when recommending a specific rate, many clients are sold by a headline rate rather than basing their decision upon the total to pay.
Another reason in these unsettled times, to use a broker to uncover some of the lenders hidden fees
Copy

Unlike Jessie J’s hit single, it is all about the money …. If you rely on the headline rate & don’t calculate the total cost of the package you’re considering, you could end up costing yourself hundreds or even thousands more in fees compared to a less appealing looking interest rate, with lower arrangement costs.
Copy

As a mortgage broker we always look to offer clients the best value product over the term of the deal. So for example on a 2 year fixed rate we take into consideration the overall cost including rates and fees, in order to find the personalised best deal for each individual client.
Copy

Lenders are trying to compete with low-interest rates compared to what they borrow the money for. Due to this, they need to take their profit from somewhere, or it wouldn't be worth it. The higher the fees, usually the lower the rate. It usually works out basically the same for all their fee structures. You may want to look at a higher rate, just to avoid the start-off costs of a bigger fee.
Copy

It's essential to do a comparison of the cost / value of the deal overall. Too often people look at fees and go for the lowest, costing themselves more in the longer term. In the current climate, however, where everyone is watching the pennies, paying less now and more later can be attractive. If ever there was a time to consult a professional to get a range of options it's now. The mortgage market has over 5700 products available but with so much choice it can be easy to go for an attractive headline price with a product that becomes a headache later.
Copy

Charles Breen
Founder at C B
Lenders are increasing thier fees so that they can have a lower more attractive headline rate, this is not always in the clients best interests but lenders dont care, as I always tell my clients , the two things that always make money in life are banks and casinos. This just further illustrates this law of nature that is as true today as it was in Cosmio Medici's day