Copy article

Are the 'Vanilla' Days of Mortgage Broking coming to an inevitable close?

ended 18. September 2025

As the world of AI descends onto the Mortgage market, High Street lenders will inevitably look to use more direct channels to deliver advice, potentially challenging the role of the mortgage broker over the coming years.

With the FCA looking to relax rules around the delivery of financial advice, this opens the way for alternative methods of contact by lenders to borrowers, using online platforms and AI technology.

So what are mortgage brokers doing now to safeguard their position in the market, with existing clients and future borrowers? Are brokers already looking to niche into specialist areas, or diversifying into neighbouring services such as investment, wills, and pensions?

In the coming years, will the High Street lenders monopolise the market, and will smaller lenders and brokers need to work closer together to develop products for those not catered for in this new AI world? Will smaller Building Societies and specialist lenders need to shout louder about what they do, and how to distribute their propositions? Do brokers need to revise their pricing, with less volumes but cases needing more time and evaluation?

The culture of mortgage broking is about to go through its most significant change in over 20 years as technology and AI take a grip on distribution. 

What do Mortgage Brokers and Smaller Lenders need to do now in readiness?

9 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Star Quote
Copy

Editor
Justin MoyVerified
Managing Director at EHF Mortgages
We have some significant changes just around the corner, and whilst there will always be borrowers who value the human touch of advice and support, AI-based systems will offer an alternative to those who prefer an online experience. The majority of my clients over the last 18 years have been served by those High Street lenders, so to make any move into specific niches is not easy; however, many will still value the expertise of experienced brokers for a while yet. This is a great time for smaller lenders and brokers to come together and work on these niche opportunities that will still need to be served, and perhaps more so in the future.
Copy

Editor
Michelle LawsonVerified
Director at Lawson Financial
Vanilla is becoming more rare as people’s lives and income become increasingly complex. Intermediaries will still be needed to unravel the difficulties and place business with the right lender. AI will assist with this but not replace it. We are adapting technology, reviewing our processes and diversifying. Being open minded and knowledgable will be key in the years ahead.
Copy

Editor
Katy EatentonVerified
Mortgage & Protection Specialist at Eatenton Finance
What is vanilla? An easy straight forward case doesn’t exist anymore. There will be a demand for a straight forward process, but the value true advise and expertise brings will still be desired by the bulk of consumers.
Copy

Editor
Daniel HobbsVerified
CEO at New Leaf Distribution
The threat of AI to the mortgage broker is real for those handling simple, or "vanilla," cases. However, this disruption is also a significant opportunity. Advisers can secure their future by explicitly moving into wealth advice, thereby becoming invaluable, long-term partners for their clients. By expanding into areas like pensions, investments, and wills, they're not just selling a product; they're providing holistic financial planning that an algorithm simply cannot replicate. This shift towards a specialised, human-centric model is where the true value lies and is the key to thriving in the new market.
Copy

Editor
Ranald MitchellVerified
Director at bad credit mortgage specialists Charwin Mortgages
Whilst many of the biggest players have struggled to fully automate the mortgage journey, the rise of AI is a clear and present danger to the ‘vanilla’ broker. For straightforward cases, human interaction is becoming less necessary as digital disruption takes hold, particularly among tech-savvy first-time buyers. But machines are just that – machines. Complex scenarios remain where human brokers add real value that algorithms cannot replicate. Common sense underwriting, context, and judgement on unique client circumstances are beyond AI’s reach. The future of broking lies in specialist advice, nuanced interpretation, and advocacy for those who don’t fit neatly into a model. Brokers who adapt and focus on complex or underserved areas will protect their role, while those who remain in the ‘vanilla’ space risk being displaced.
Copy

Editor
Ken JamesVerified
Director at Contractor Mortgage Services
High street lenders may dominate with their ability to incoporate AI and this will impact on brokers and the banks staffing volume, but what AI will not give them is the personality of a Broker, but we need to adapt Let’s be honest the pressure is increasing. As technology transforms the mortgage landscape, the traditional model of a solo broker relying on repeat business, referrals, and lender panels will need to evolve but that doesn’t mean we are obsolete.
It means you must adapt, specialise, and clearly define your worth to the client.
The new mortgage ecosystem has room for both machine and mind and the brokers and lenders who balance the two will not just survive, but lead.
Copy

Editor
Dariusz KarpowiczVerified
Director at Albion Financial Advice
While many in the broker community believe AI will only threaten vanilla cases, leaving specialist lending untouched, I'm not buying it. AI systems will master all criteria - including the most niche specialist ones - update faster than any broker ever could, work 24/7 without holidays, and deliver consistent excellence without fatigue.
The uncomfortable truth is there's no real preparation for this seismic shift; it's not a question of if AI will replace brokers, but when. UK regulation might slow the inevitable due to our conservative approach, but it's merely buying time. The human touch, relationship building, and complex case expertise that brokers pride themselves on will eventually be replicated by algorithms that never have an off day, never miss a deadline, and never forget a client's circumstances.
Copy

Kundan BhaduriVerified
Entrepreneur, Investor and Landlord at The Kushman Group
Basic rate and term mortgages for straightforward employed borrowers can now be processed by algorithms that work faster, cheaper, and without coffee breaks.

High street lenders are quietly building direct channels that will bypass brokers entirely for simple cases, leaving the industry to fight over complex deals and specialist lending. The smart brokers saw this coming five years ago and pivoted into areas where human judgment still matters: self employed clients, portfolio landlords, non standard construction, and bridging finance.

The survivors will be those who become genuine advisers rather than form fillers. That means expanding into protection, pensions, investment advice, and estate planning. Building societies and specialist lenders need these relationships more than ever because their products require explanation rather than automation.
Copy

Hannah BashfordVerified
Director at Model Financial Solutions
If the last 5 years have taught us anything it’s that there is no longer a ‘vanilla’ case.
Cases that are seemingly straightforward, rarely are anymore with complex incomes, property types, credit scores/ usage and valuations making things difficult, not to mention rate changes and keeping on top of deadlines.

The difference is between convenience and the value of advice and we are a relationship business. Going forward if you want to keep a client bank you’ll have to make sure you are trusted and knowledgeable and you’ll stand out if you have a person picking up the phone instead of a robot live chat!

Working with AI and technology to make the process as streamlined as possible is going to be a huge benefit but if a person can see the value you are providing they will still use an adviser.