Copy article

Should he stay or should he go?

ended 02. October 2025

The future of Manchester United manager, Ruben Amorim, it a hot topic this week with speculation increasing by the hour. Should he go? And if you think he should, who should replace him? Video and text responses welcome. This story and your views will be sent to news media tomorrow AM. Deadline is 08:00.

2 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Amorim has to stay. Manchester United’s biggest problem isn’t the manager, it’s the revolving door the board keeps spinning. You can’t build a winning culture when every 18 months you rip it up and start again. Amorim deserves time, trust and backing, not to be the next scapegoat.
Copy

Amorim has collected one of the fewest points for any Manchester United manager with over 30 games in charge. It’s clear he remains unsure of his best team or style of play, and what worked at his previous club simply hasn’t translated at Old Trafford. That said, the problems go deeper than the dugout. Too many players lack quality, direction and drive. What was once the highest standard of football in England has slipped into something closer to a playground, and that decline started long before Amorim arrived.

If change does come, United need a proven leader with experience of managing big players and big pressure. Someone like Zinedine Zidane, who commands respect instantly, could provide the reset the club badly needs.