Copy article

Why are fewer people complaining about financial firms/products?

Journalist: Marc Shoffman, Freelance

ended 30. April 2025

FCA data shows a drop in consumer complaints about financial products.

https://www.fca.org.uk/data/firm-level-complaints-data-sortable-table

I am writing an article for MoneyWeek on this and am keen for comments. Why has there been a drop? Are financial firms really treating customers better? Is the consumer duty working?

Kind regards

Marc

4 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Fewer people are complaining for a multitude of reasons. Firstly, it is made too hard where people have to write or email and consumers are time poor now. Many are also of the opinion that there is little point as nothing will be done and their complaint will be just resolved via a small amount of negligable compensation or goodwill with a letter of apology. We also hear all too often that lessons will be learned but they rarely are. It's a perfect storm resulting in people wondering 'what's the point?'.
Copy

I would like to think that consumer duty is responsible for improved service and fairness being provided to clients, and therefore less complaints being made. However, the FCA figures show reported complaints as the system requires the company to self-declare these figures in their returns. So it could also be mis-reporting or issues being dealt with and resolved quickly before becoming official complaints. The other alternatve is if clients have become disillusioned about complaints on financial firms and the ombudsman and see it as more hassle than benefit.
Copy

Clients are distracted by a flatlining economy, rising inflation, and a stronger Pound, shifting focus from complaints across sectors like banking, home finance, insurance, investments, and pensions. Fading PPI effects, tighter lending rules, and the FCA’s 2016 rule change (3-day informal resolution) likely contributed to the drop, not improved firm behavior. Are firms doing better? Unlikely—the unchanged 58% complaint uphold rate shows persistent issues. It’s too soon to credit Consumer Duty’s July 2023 rollout, as complaints were already declining. High uphold rates and slow resolutions highlight ongoing consumer harm and systemic flaws. Firms must leverage complaint data better, and the FCA should enforce Duty more rigorously to drive real change.
Copy

The plummeting complaints about financial products is either the financial sector's redemption arc or simply consumers waving the white flag of surrender. Perhaps the Consumer Duty has actually accomplished what decades of regulation couldn't by forcing firms to treat customers as more than walking wallets? I suspect it is a case of firms having become simply more cleverer at heading off problems before they trigger formal grumbles. The cynical view (which I subscribe to) is that we're all just too knackered to fill in yet another feedback form. Nevertheless, if financial institutions are finally behaving themselves, it's rather like spotting Nessie riding a unicorn – improbable but not entirely impossible.