Copy article

Comments wanted from tax and savings experts about what the impact of continued frozen tax thresholds will be

ended 22. September 2025

Request from the Mail:

I'm looking for comment from tax and savings experts about what the impact of continued frozen tax thresholds will be. 

For example, if someone's salary increases, they could end up losing their tax-free savings allowance or it could drop to £500. Are there any other implications of these frozen tax thresholds? 

Responses ASAP please.

8 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Frozen thresholds are warping behaviour. I see high earners turning down pay rises, cutting back to four days a week or feeling trapped because an extra £1 can mean losing childcare hours and being taxed at an effective 60%. It’s not just income tax – your Personal Savings Allowance halves at higher rate and disappears at additional rate, while funded childcare support falls away the moment adjusted net income tips over £100k. Many don’t realise that paying into a pension can bring them back below the line, keeping vital benefits while building long-term wealth. These freezes aren’t just raising revenue without having to announce a tax rise, they’re reshaping how people work, save and plan. The bigger risk is that government underestimates the damage to economic output.
Copy

Frozen tax thresholds, or fiscal drag, are a stealth tax used by governments of all colours for as long as I can remember. They mean you pay more tax each year even if you’re no better off in real terms. The bigger problem is the cliff edges when modest pay rises push people into higher tax bands. For example, under the new Winter Fuel rules, a pension increase of just £1 over £35,000 would lose the allowance entirely. Similarly, someone on the cusp of higher rate income tax, with £25,000 on deposit earning 4% interest (£1,000 a year) could see a £500 pay rise push them into the higher-rate band. That would not only cost £210 in income tax and NI but also £200 more in tax on their savings — an effective 82% rate on that pay rise. These cliff edges are especially damaging and unfair.
Copy

The ongoing freeze on tax thresholds is a stealth tax in all but name and it’s no longer just the highest earners feeling the squeeze. More and more middle earners are being dragged into higher tax bands, losing valuable allowances and facing tax bills on income and savings that were previously protected. Labour may claim not to be raising taxes for working people, but these frozen thresholds effectively do the same job for them quietly.
Copy

62% Tax and Lost Benefits . The Stealth Traps, Hitting Families Hard. The £100k income level is no longer the preserve of the wealthy but crossing it unleashes some of the harshest quirks in the tax system. Once you earn above £100,000, you lose your personal allowance at £1 for every £2 of income, meaning it’s gone by £125,140. Add National Insurance and the effective rate is a punishing 62% marginal tax. It doesn’t stop there. All taxable income counts, even so-called “tax-free” allowances on savings interest and dividends, which can push you over the £100k line and claw back your PA. Families are hit twice: Child Benefit is now tapered away and gone completely at £80,000. For a household with two children, that means losing around £1,800 per year. Cross £100k and you also lose access to tax-free childcare support worth £2000 per year. With wages rising and thresholds frozen, more households are dragged into higher bands, taxed on “tax-free” income, and stripped of their benefits.
Copy

Someone crossing £100,000 in income immediately faces effective marginal rates exceeding 60% as a result of their personal allowance being withdrawn. Be under no illusion, this is no accidental drift but a deliberate government policy, that uses inflation to raise taxes while Labour claim they have kept rates unchanged for the 'working people' (whatever that means).

These perverse incentives are economically destructive. Entrepreneurs delay salary increases to avoid threshold traps while employees negotiate shorter working weeks rather than face punitive marginal rates.

This British government is systematically penalising success, innovation, and hard work through a tax system that treats modest pay rises like lottery winnings. Starmer's fiscal vandalism is discouraging exactly the economic behavior the country desperately needs.
Copy

The continued freeze on tax thresholds means that even modest pay rises can drag individuals into higher tax brackets, creating what’s known as “fiscal drag.” As wages rise with inflation, more people find themselves paying 40% income tax without necessarily feeling any richer in real terms. For savers, this also risks losing valuable allowances. For example, once an individual’s income exceeds £50,270, their personal savings allowance falls from £1,000 to £500, and at higher income levels, it disappears completely, leaving more of their interest earnings taxable.

Beyond savings, frozen thresholds also affect access to child benefit (via the High Income Child Benefit Charge), personal allowances (which taper away once income exceeds £100,000), and pension tax relief. Many families may be surprised to discover that what seems like a modest salary increase can tip them into a higher effective tax rate once these thresholds interact.
Copy

Freezing tax thresholds is a common way for the Treasury to increase its tax take through something called 'fiscal drag' – this is where taxpayers are pushed into higher tax brackets or suffer reduced eligibility for benefits despite unchanged tax rates. We've all seen how inflation has affected households, and with wages having risen to keep up with price rises, keeping tax bands frozen reduces people's spending power further.
Copy

Frozen thresholds is nothing but a secret tax. People are starting to turn down promotions and new jobs, because the unfavourable tax treatment could mean they are in fact worse off. It sounds and is ridiculous.