Are IFAs seeing more AI-generated requests to validate pre-selected advice?
Financial advisers may increasingly be asked to validate investment strategies already drafted or heavily shaped by AI.
Scott Gallacher, Chartered Financial Planner at Rowley Turton, reports receiving a recent enquiry in which a prospective client presented a highly detailed, pre-selected investment strategy and sought formal adviser sign-off for a fixed fee.
The proposal was professionally presented and used technically credible language, but closer scrutiny raised concerns over whether some of the underlying assumptions were valid.
Gallacher says the issue is not whether clients should use AI. The concern is that AI can produce detailed and convincing financial-planning proposals that may appear more robust than they really are.
That could create a new challenge for advisers: distinguishing between a genuine request for independent advice and a request simply to validate a conclusion that has already been reached.
Questions for experts
- Are you seeing more clients arrive with investment or financial-planning strategies that appear to have been generated or heavily influenced by AI?
- Are clients becoming more prescriptive about the product, structure or strategy they want advisers to recommend?
- Have you encountered AI-generated proposals that sound credible but contain technical errors or flawed assumptions?
- How should advisers respond when they are effectively being asked to “sign off” a predetermined solution?
- Does this create a new professional or regulatory risk for advisers?
- Will firms need clearer policies on how they deal with AI-generated client briefs?




