Are IFAs seeing more AI-generated requests to validate pre-selected advice?

ended 06. October 2026

Financial advisers may increasingly be asked to validate investment strategies already drafted or heavily shaped by AI.

Scott Gallacher, Chartered Financial Planner at Rowley Turton, reports receiving a recent enquiry in which a prospective client presented a highly detailed, pre-selected investment strategy and sought formal adviser sign-off for a fixed fee.

The proposal was professionally presented and used technically credible language, but closer scrutiny raised concerns over whether some of the underlying assumptions were valid.

Gallacher says the issue is not whether clients should use AI. The concern is that AI can produce detailed and convincing financial-planning proposals that may appear more robust than they really are.

That could create a new challenge for advisers: distinguishing between a genuine request for independent advice and a request simply to validate a conclusion that has already been reached.

Questions for experts

  • Are you seeing more clients arrive with investment or financial-planning strategies that appear to have been generated or heavily influenced by AI?
  • Are clients becoming more prescriptive about the product, structure or strategy they want advisers to recommend?
  • Have you encountered AI-generated proposals that sound credible but contain technical errors or flawed assumptions?
  • How should advisers respond when they are effectively being asked to “sign off” a predetermined solution?
  • Does this create a new professional or regulatory risk for advisers?
  • Will firms need clearer policies on how they deal with AI-generated client briefs?

4 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Story Source
Copy

Pro
Scott GallacherVerified
Director at Rowley Turton
iContact details are shown to logged-in members. Log in
I understand why clients and prospects use AI. Well-informed prospects can make some of the best clients because they arrive engaged and ready to have a meaningful conversation. The problem is that misinformed prospects can mean you start on the wrong foot, and they may then dig in.

On one recent enquiry, the proposal looked sophisticated and technically credible at a cursory glance, but to an experienced adviser, an obvious technical error stood out.

What was particularly striking was that, although we spotted the issue immediately, our own AI tools initially sided with the original proposal. Only after deeper research, checking primary sources, and repeatedly challenging the answer did the AI finally acknowledge the issue.

That is the real danger: AI can sound incredibly convincing while still being wrong, and some errors may only become apparent after the event.
Copy

Pro
Ross LaceyVerified
Director at Fairview Financial Management
iContact details are shown to logged-in members. Log in
We've had a couple of odd enquiries from prospective clients who had clearly used AI to formulate their questions, including about Roth conversions and Medicare which are only relevant in the US.
Copy

Pro
Nouran MoustafaVerified
Practice Principal & IFA at Roxton Wealth
iContact details are shown to logged-in members. Log in
I would never “sign off” an AI-generated investment strategy simply because it looks sophisticated.

AI can produce an immaculate 20-page plan full of asset allocations, tax wrappers and technical language, while building the whole thing on one wrong assumption. Confidence is not competence.

If I give regulated advice, I own the suitability of that advice. The fact a client, ChatGPT or another AI chose the portfolio first does not transfer that responsibility.

I am happy for clients to use AI, and I use it myself, but I would rebuild the recommendation from the client upwards: goals, tax position, capacity for loss, risk, time horizon and existing assets.

The danger is confirmation shopping: asking an adviser to bless a conclusion rather than challenge it.

AI should make clients better informed. It should never turn an adviser into a rubber stamp.
Copy

Pro
Tony RedondoVerified
Founder at Cosmos Currency Exchange
iContact details are shown to logged-in members. Log in
The same trend is hitting FX and corporate treasury. Clients, from SMEs to international property buyers now arrive with AI-generated currency blueprints. Instead of describing a problem, they dictate the solution: specific hedging ratios, structured derivatives, the lot. That is dangerous. AI writes with persuasive technical fluency, delta hedging, forward points yet routinely bakes in flawed assumptions. It treats forward rates as predictions rather than interest rate differentials, ignores bid-ask spreads, and overlooks the real cost of collateral, margin calls and credit lines. Ask a broker for a quick "sign-off" on a ready-made AI plan and suitability liability lands squarely on him or her and they only get paid if they win the business. Regulatory, professional indemnity and reputational risk follow. I won't be a rubber stamp. Clients should weigh their options; the broker's job is to perform due diligence and provide costed choices.