Copy article

Angela Rayner's resignation "shows that getting the right advice isn’t optional, it’s essential"

ended 05. September 2025

Angela Rayner's resignation "shows that getting the right advice isn’t optional, it’s essential", financial experts say.

She has resigned as Deputy PM and Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, following her failure to pay sufficient stamp duty on a flat she purchased. 

At the centre of the issue is a £40,000 tax liability linked to the timing of a property transaction. 

While headlines have focused on the tax itself, the bigger story is the knock-on consequences, experts say. 

The fallout has threatened her political career, her reputation, and her position — costing far greater than the tax bill alone.

With the right financial and tax advice, she’d likely have been told to hold off buying the flat until her son turned 18, experts said.

That small change in timing could have saved £40,000 — and spared her career, they add.

Eamonn Prendergast, Chartered Financial Adviser at Bromley-based Palantir Financial Planning Ltd, said: "Angela Rayner’s case shows that getting the right advice at the right time isn’t optional, it’s essential. Conveyancers handle the legal paperwork, but they don’t give specialist tax advice, and this case involved multiple moving parts: tax, trusts, stamp duty and valuations. 

“The £40,000 bill (plus penalties and interest) still needed to be paid but the far greater cost was the damage to Rayner's reputation and career. The lesson is clear: not all advisers are the same, and when property, family and tax collide, expert advice is far cheaper than the price of mistakes.”

Scott Gallacher, Director at Leicester-based Rowley Turton, said he sees people every day who make costly mistakes due to a lack of advice.

He continued: "People often focus too much on the cost of advice rather than the value of it. This case highlights the danger of assuming things are simple and straightforward, when in reality there are often hidden pitfalls. 

“Almost every day we see clients who could have made simple but very costly mistakes. For example, one client stood to lose £80,000 by taking his pension benefits in the wrong way – a mistake avoided through timely advice.”

Riz Malik, Director at Southend-on-Sea-based R3 Wealth, urged people to speak to a professional about financial advice.

He added: “Doing it yourself can be extremely costly in the long run. I regularly tell clients to seek specialist tax or legal advice in areas that I am not qualified to advise them, and work closely with advisers, accountants and solicitors. 

"With all the changes that are coming up with pensions, inheritance tax and whatever the budget may hold, if you are not sure, speak to a professional.”

Rob Mansfield, Independent Financial Advisor at Rootes Wealth Management, said tax rules are not easy to decipher.

He added: "'Tax doesn't have to be taxing' was the advertising slogan used by the tax office to promote doing it yourself, but the reality is that tax is complicated and the rules are arcane. 

"If the politicians who set the rules can't follow them, what hope do regular people have? This is one of the benefits of taking professional advice as it reduces the chance of making a mistake."

6 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Star Quote
Copy

Angela Rayner’s case shows that getting the right advice at the right time isn’t optional, it’s essential. Conveyancers handle the legal paperwork, but they don’t give specialist tax advice, and this case involved multiple moving parts: tax, trusts, stamp duty and valuations. The £40,000 bill (plus penalties and interest) still needed to be paid but the far greater cost was the damage to Rayner's reputation and career. The lesson is clear: not all advisers are the same, and when property, family and tax collide, expert advice is far cheaper than the price of mistakes.
Star Quote
Copy

People often focus too much on the cost of advice rather than the value of it. This case highlights the danger of assuming things are simple and straightforward, when in reality there are often hidden pitfalls. Almost every day we see clients who could have made simple but very costly mistakes. For example, one client stood to lose £80,000 by taking his pension benefits in the wrong way — a mistake avoided through timely advice.
Copy

Doing it yourself can be extremely costly in the long run. I regularly tell clients to seek specialist tax or legal advice in areas that I am not qualified to advise them, and work closely with advisers, accountants and solicitors. With all the changes that are coming up with pensions, inheritance tax and whatever the budget may hold, if you are not sure, speak to a professional.
Copy

"Tax doesn't have to be taxing" was the advertising slogan used by the tax office to promote doing it yourself, but the reality is that tax is complicated and the rules are arcane. If the politicians who set the rules can't follow them, what hope do regular people have? This is one of the benefits of taking professional advice as it reduces the chance of making a mistake.
Copy

This is basic. Stamp duty is something that every homeowner should be aware of. As a mortgage advisor, this is addressed in our first appointment with a client, and while we don't give tax advice, we would advise a client to seek it and we would also point them in the direction of the government's stamp duty calculator. This case highlights that everyone should be getting qualified advice when purchasing a property. If you are receiving regulated advice and you make an error, then the blame lies with the professional that advises you.
Copy

Angela Rayner misled the public when she claimed to have received tax advice. She based her understanding on guidance from the conveyancer, who twice advised her to seek independent tax advice. This emphasises the importance of specialist advice. It serves as a warning to advisers across the housing sector not to try to be a "Jack of all trades, master of none". This small family conveyancing firm is saved by doing the job correctly, referring tax matters to a tax specialist. Angela tried to throw them under the bus, but the independent auditor report stopped that in its tracks.