FT Logo

Copy article

FT Editor Banner

Tariff turmoil - Are smoothed funds the answer?

Journalist: Carmen Reichman, FTAdviser

ended 26. April 2025

Dear advisers

I've got two questions:

First, how did/do you manage the market turmoil cuased by Trump's tariff policies? Did you shift clients' money into bonds or gold, did you do nothing? Is there anything that you did that has gone well and that you'd like to share?

How do you plan to respond to further volatility? Are you getting a lot of enquiries from nervous clients? Would you say it's more about calming the nerves of clients or managing the actual investments?

Second, to what extent do you use smoothed funds to manage volatility? And why/why not? Are here any other risk managed products you use instead, especially in retirement solutions?

Thanks very much! I look forward to reading your responses.

Carmen, carmen.reichman@ft.com

4 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Markets are volatile, it's in their nature and so periods like this are to be expected. I've stuck with what we've got for the time being. We've seen indiscriminate selling and we need the dust to settle. At the moment it feels we'd be jumping out of the frying pan into the fire and there's a real danger we could lock in losses.
Clients are understandably frustrated and lay the blame at Trump who is a wild card. We don't even know what things will look like at the end of this 90 day pause. I don't see the value in trying to guess what he'll do next.
For retirement solutions I like including an element of structured products. If the profile looks good you can get strong returns with decent downside protection. They can help soften volatility in the market based part of the portfolio.
I find smoothed funds are a bit like property. They give an illusion of stability by not being under the daily valuation microscope. I'm yet to be convinced they offer genuine value.
Copy

As a discretionary manager, we have the mandate to adjust portfolios as we see fit. Having said that, portfolios are managed to the outcomes of a financial plan and are well diversified regardless. It was clear that volatility was going to become more permanant with a Trump presidency although noone knew the extent of this of course. We have always held a Gold allocation within portfolios as it is ussually a good support to portfolios in times of stress. We have increased this position over the last 2 years and it has done extremely well with other drivers influencing its value. Whilst volatility is a function of markets and knee jerk reactions are often the worst thing to do, prior to April 2nd and the following days we did trim US equity allocations and added to our Gold and Defence positions.
Communication is everything so regular mass and client specific communication has meant that any nervous clients calls can be counted on one hand & ussually event driven for them.
Copy

We believe in staying the course—provided the portfolio is well-diversified and aligned to the client’s risk profile and goals. Timing the market, especially during tariff turmoil and Trump’s policy flip-flops, is near impossible. We've had few nervous client calls, as our planning ensures clients understand the risks upfront. Some have sensibly opted to use cash reserves instead of portfolio withdrawals. As for smoothed funds, I’m generally not a fan. I liken them to a frog in an iron box—markets naturally jump around, and smoothed funds can give a false sense of calm. The risk is that the “iron box” turns out to be a wet paper bag, and when the frog (the market) breaks out and the smoothing proves not so smooth or secure, investors are shocked. We prefer transparent, well-diversified strategies over artificial smoothing—especially for retirement income.
Copy

When we added gold to lower and moderate risk portfolios in 2019, it wasn’t due to price predictions. It was because of how gold behaves in a portfolio. It’s volatile, but its movements are often uncorrelated with equities and bonds. That means it can rise when other assets fall which is useful in times of crisis. But in strong equity markets, gold can be a drag. We were fine with that because it helped smooth out returns and reduce volatility for clients. That’s more important to us than short-term price action. Today, just like in 2019, we’re not pretending to know what drives gold prices: geopolitics, central banks, wedding season? Maybe. Maybe not. Gold still earns its place by helping clients stay on track through market ups and downs.