Copy article

Stocks and shares ISAs hold large amounts of cash

Journalist: Samantha Downes

ended 25. February 2025

Looking for comment and verification that at least 5% of money invested in stocks and shares is held in cash - so adding to the debate around cash ISAs.

Interested in thoughts!

3 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

There will very often be some money held in cash within a stocks and shares ISA. This could be to cover any ongoing fees and charges, but also some investment managers will strategically hold cash which can be used to buy into investments when they feel the price has fallen to a more attractive level. There are also those who may have transferred a cash ISA into a stock and shares ISA, and not want to gradually phase this cash into the market, which means they'll hold a higher than average cash balance. Should the rumours be true around the Chancellor reducing the allowance for cash ISAs, it'll be interesting to see how this is policed given there's not currently any mechanism to limit how much of a stocks and shares ISA is held as pure cash.
Copy

In the UK, there is a growing hidden cash pile within S&S ISAs, with billions remaining on the sidelines, diluting the investment performance of these portfolios and presenting a significant opportunity cost for investors. Against a backdrop of persistent inflation concerns and shifting monetary policy, investors need to reassess whether this cash buffer is a prudent hedge or just a performance drag. Many IFAs advocate for a one-size-fits-all approach to cash reserves, typically around 5%, however, this advice is outdated and not suitable in our higher-rate environment, where a flexible approach is crucial. Within our flagship Sad Rabbit model portfolio, we use a totally dynamic approach to portfolio allocation, ensuring that cash is optimally deployed based on shifting market conditions. At present, our portfolio holds a 2.1% cash allocation, a significant reduction from 4.8% last year, reflecting declining forward yields and increasing opportunities in select global markets.
Copy

This makes sense. It's a cash buffer in investment portfolios to pay fees (although we hold only 0.5% in our portfolios and rebalance quarterly to ensure it's always there). However you can easily replicate the cash in a cash ISA with sterling money market funds — funds that hold multiple deposits and very short term gilts in various banks.