Copy article

Seeking defamation and legal experts

Journalist: Arthur Parashar, MailOnline

ended 10. April 2024

We are doing a piece around a Facebook page called Are We Dating The Same Guy? where women can warn each other of 'men who might be liars, cheaters, abusers or exhibit any type of toxic or dangerous behaviour.'

It now appears that men who have been wrongfully exposed are fighting back against the page. There have been lawsuits in the US (e.g. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-13224259/are-dating-guy-la-sues-women-murderer.html ) over defamation, sex-based discrimination, intentional infliction of emotional distress, libel and invasion of privacy.

We now want to do a UK-facing piece on this. 

Could women in the UK be sued over these Facebook posts if they turn out to be false? Should these users be careful with what they are sharing?

1 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Yes potentially those who make false statements can be sued for defamation, known as libel when written down. To succeed, a claimant needs to show four things: 1) the statement is defamatory, that is an ordinary person would think less of them; 2) the statement identifies them clearly; 3) third parties have seen the statement and; 4) claimants must now also demonstrate that the publication of the statement caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to their reputation. It is the last limb that is likely to mean most normal people would never bring a defamation claim. They’re the reserve of the rich and famous, because a false statement can material impact their reputation and cause financial loss. Dave down the pub less so. Moreover, the costs of bringing a defamation claim are horrendous - six figures easily - and so again most normal folk can’t afford to go to the Courts.