Copy article

Scaling back net zero

Journalist: Gillian Duncan, The National

ended 22. September 2023

Hello, I'm writing about the plan to scale back net zero plans. I'm looking for some opinions from businesses on this - is this a good thing or a bad thing from your perspective? Thanks 

13 responses from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Net zero plans are an immediate necessity for the planet, and this scaling back shows the short-sightedness of this current government. We all need to make changes to help the environment, whether legislated or not. Having a look at world weather events and it's obvious climate change is happening.
Copy

An unbelievable U turn on the electric car deadline! Instead of being at the forefront of the technological rollout as manufacturers geared up to the earliest deadline around the world - 2030, we will not only become an alsoran in the vehicular race to electrification of our roads we will drop to the bottom of the pile given the design and manufacturing challenges as we stick our steering wheels on the right-hand side of the car.

Given the urgency of the 2030 deadline we were lined up at the head of the queue as the latest technology was rolled out, batteries with longer ranges and charge times that could be measured in seconds rather than minutes and hours would have been in our cars before the rest of the world to encourage sales or face fines.

We may be the second largest auto market in Europe but in 2019 we sold 2.3 million cars in the UK compared to 13.5 LHD cars in Europe. Instead of leading the way we'll simply become an afterthought. A modified Euro-Car market.
Copy

To build a Net Zero industry with the right supply chain capacity, it takes time, money and resource. Businesses, many being SMEs, have already invested in skills, research and development, and equipment to become part of our growing green economy. The movement will have taken a few steps back with this latest news, but what’s important now is consistency so businesses know how to plan for the future. Hopefully for now, the positive news we can take from this is more breathing space for those who have not yet been able to prioritise net zero in their business strategies.
Copy

The UK had a real opportunity to be a world leader when it comes to net zero, instead the Government has cemented it's position as a world leader in u-turns.

Manufacturing businesses have been crying out for certainty and stability following global events over the last few years, and yesterday's announcement is yet more policy flip-flopping.

Seriously, how are businesses meant to plan for anything meaningful if the goalposts are going to be shifted every year or so?! It's embarrassing that the UK is the only major economy without a proper industrial strategy - the sooner we get a long-term national manufacturing plan, the better.
Copy

Frankly it's idiotic. Businesses had been gearing up for expected legislation changes only for the goalposts to be moved for what feels like the umpteenth time with this government.

A government that clearly couldn't care less about businesses, normal people or in this case the future of life on Earth when it comes to desperately trying to save their own skin.
Copy

The government yet again shows its commitment to the short term by another U-turn that avoids investing in the countries, and the planets future. While other country's transition to a cleaner future the UK will fall behind. We have the opportunity to lead in net zero technologies, and that should not be a goal businesses should give up on, but it should be supported by the government.

A real shame, and yet another failure by this government.

Copy

While corporations greenwash, and governments flip-flop, small business owners are taking matters into their own hands, creating their own net zero (or net negative) plans - with immediate effect.

They're not waiting for some arbitrary target more than two decades (or longer) away. They're taking action now - from the school wall art company planting a tree for each ream of paper they use, to the food delivery company committing to a 100% electric fleet and compostable materials. The accountant who refuses to fly to conferences, and the law firm building wells in Kenya.

Small business owners understand: "If it's to be, it's up to me."
Copy

While climate change policies are undeniably vital for our planet's future, the financial toll on everyday individuals, especially those in low to middle-income brackets, cannot be ignored. The government's pace of enacting these policies, such as the EPC regulations for landlords, is unsettling. With escalating costs in the housing market, higher taxes and rising interest rates, landlords are already burdened. Mandating costly upgrades without ample financial aid can strain an already stressed economy. A balanced approach is needed, one where the government provides grants to alleviate the financial burdens of these rapid policy changes. This would be a more realistic and sustainable route to achieving our net-zero ambitions.
Copy

While I recognise that the original timelines for getting to net zero by 2050 were challenging, surely good politics (and therefore good policies) should be about meeting challenging goals, not moving the goal posts 5 miles down the road so they are then effectively out of sight, out of mind.

We should be sticking to the original targets, provide certainty and maintain our position in the global marketplace. As it is, we risk being sidelined for major international investment.

When Sunak said his announcement yesterday was not about politics, I'm surprised his nose didn't grow by the second! Of course it was about politics, it was dog whistle politics to the right of his party and the climate change deniers.

I will credit him though that it was clever politics. Will Keir Starmer have the cojones to stand up and say Labour would restore all the original goals and dates? Only he knows the answer to that one......
Copy

Selling it as a noble act that puts money back into the pockets of the poorest in society is, well, frankly quite ridiculous. First of all, let's get one thing straight – these energy improvements are aimed at landlords, not homeowners and certainly not tenants. If the government genuinely cared about landlords, they might consider repealing Section 24, allowing us to treat our interest as a legitimate cost.

Imagine for a moment if this punitive, interventionist legislation were history. Landlords would have some extra cash to invest in those energy upgrades and meet the new EPC standards. But here's the kicker: without these upgrades, guess who's going to feel the heat (literally)? It's the tenants, my friends. Energy bills will keep soaring, especially in regions where property investment is scarcer than a snowflake in July. With the housing shortage in the UK, the energy rating of a property is about as influential as a gnat in a hurricane when it comes to rental prices.
Copy

We are investing significant time and resources into obtaining B Corp certification. As a small web design agency owner, achieving this distinction is not just a badge—it's a testament to our commitment to ethical and sustainable practices. It's disheartening to see the goalposts being moved.

Changing the deadline not only sends the message that it's not a pressing matter but also jeopardises the trust and efforts of businesses like ours.
Copy

As a homeworker who only uses a little power for the laptop, phone and kettle (all essential work tools), I feel that we are doing our bit for zero emissions.
Maybe we should look into traffic, this seems to be on the increase and the amount of Co2 being emitted from wasted oil/fuel being burnt on the M25 carpark may just help to tip the scales.
Copy

Jo Spolton
Founder at Rumage
The government is completely focused on the short-term and election polls, whereas the small and emerging businesses in the UK are all focused on the financial and environmental long term.

In the world of startups, the majority are taking environmental impact seriously; being carbon neutral or as close as they can be is key to their value proposition.

Many new businesses now are entirely built around carbon reduction and enabling consumers to live life with a lighter tread. We are the leaders who are taking action and absorbing the risk. It is incredibly saddening to see the UK going backwards in its efforts to achieve net zero, let alone achieve what we really need which is to be climate-positive.
Building business plans which are stable enough to attract investment is hard when direction of travel for policies is not stable. The UK has missed our chance to be a country that leads