Copy article

How to avoid becoming an ‘equity punk’: advice on speculative investments

Journalist Media RequestiThe journalist's name and outlet are shown to Plus and Pro members. Log in

ended 09. March 2026

News that BrewDog has been sold for £33m, with many retail shareholders from its “Equity for Punks” crowdfunding rounds likely to see little or no return, is a reminder of the risks of narrative-led investments.

It raises broader questions about how advisers deal with speculative or illiquid investment ideas, particularly when clients are enthusiastic about them.

Advisers:

What is the most concerning or speculative investment you have discovered when onboarding a new client?

Have you ever failed or succeeded in persuading a client not to commit significant capital to a high-risk opportunity? What made the difference?

What red flags do you look for when clients bring you unlisted, crowdfunded or narrative led-investments?

When an investment does go wrong, how do you manage the client relationship and any compliance risk?

1 response from the Newspage community

Copy all

Copy

Jordan Reid
Chartered Financial Planner at Serenity Financial Planning
iContact details are shown to logged-in members. Log in
Following a tip from an "expert" on YouTube, a new client held investments spread across three different US based Cannabis stocks. By the time I had a chance to do anything, these speculative investments were, sadly, up in smoke. The money was lost and a lesson was learnt.

Through ongoing education, the client has avoided making another investing mistake. But the temptation is always there with finfluencers and social media a constant distraction. I simply remind the client "How did that work out for you last time?"